Archive for the ‘Sciatica’ Category

New Study on TENS therapy, Footwear, and some Feedback

Thursday, January 7th, 2010

New Study on TENS therapy

A recent update to guidelines by the American Academy of Neurology based upon a study by the University of Kansas Medical Center suggested that a commonly used treatment modality, TENS, was not effective in the treatment of chronic low back pain.

TENS therapy has been in wide use for over 40 years, and many patients have reported benefit from it. The study implied that there was no clear benefit, but that the clinician should use their judgement to determine if it should be used on a particular patient.

Now, I do not use TENS in my office- however, pretty much all of the physical therapists I refer to do, and the patients I have spoken with frequently see benefit from the treatment. So what are we supposed to make of this study? Well, first of all- pain is a subjective issue. Unfortunately, there is really no way to objectively quantify pain. If a patient is telling me they are getting relief from a treatment that has no down side, I am ok with continuing it. The issue for you is going to be coverage. Up until now, it has been reasonably easy to obtain a TENS unit if you had a complaint of back pain. WIth these new guidelines, it will be harder to get a home unit, and I suspect physical therapist will cease to get paid when they perform it in the office. It will be interesting to see how this pans out.

A Quick Thought on Sneakers

A patient came in last week with complaints of low back pain which occurred when they were jogging. Now, there are lots of potential causes for back pain with exercise activities, but this patient’s pain developed over the course of several weeks without a change in their exercise regimen, and no injury or trauma.

As I went through his history, complaints, and physical exam- I eventually got to the topic of footwear. Was he wearing shoes appropriate to his sport? Yes. How old were his shoes? About 18 months….

Since he was running indoors on a treadmill, his shoes looked pretty much new- so he never thought to replace them.

Current shoe technology can do much to absorb the shock of sports activity- however, like all things, they can eventually wear out. Quality footwear, with good supportive arches, and shock absorption will prevent the impact of exercise from being transmitted up through your body and into your spine. If you work out regularly, it is probably a good idea to replace your sneaker every 6 months or so.

Feedback on Donna’s Piece Last Week

Thank you so much for your very kind thoughts on my wife Donna’s contribution last week- I forwarded all of your comments to her. She is already working on her next contribution. I cannot wait so see what she posts!

We are getting ready for more snow here in Philadelphia. Stay warm, and as always, be well.

-Andy

Philadelphia Flower Show- Every February, reminding us that the winter will end, eventually...

Philadelphia Flower Show- Every February, reminding us that the winter will end, eventually…

Follow up on Desk Chairs, Deb Rasansky’s One Thing…

Tuesday, January 5th, 2010

Thanks for the feedback on Deb Rasansky’s ‘One Thing.’ The thing about asking someone to summarize their very best suggestion in 90 seconds or less is that I may have to elaborate a little on their suggestion so you get the ‘meat.’ Here’s a follow up on Deb’s post….

followupdeskchair

The video shot is a little wonky- No tripod!!!!

Odds & Ends; Snow, Sports Concussions & Brains, New Studies, etc…

Monday, December 21st, 2009

What a weekend! The snow started on Friday, and didn’t stop until Sunday morning- the whole area got blasted. With the blizzard, came the flood of emails recommending that I do a post on the safe shoveling of snow. I thought about it, but as I watched the news I realized that EVERY news outlet was already running their respective pieces on shoveling snow- how to avoid back pain, how to not have a heart attack, how to stay warm while shoveling- and my personal favorite: How to shovel out your car without getting wrangled into digging out your neighbors’. A little selfish, I think.

In this case, I will be the rebel, and not say anything about shoveling and back pain- I’ll leave that one to the ‘experts.’ Partially because it has already been played out ad nauseum, and partially because my back is pretty sore from shoveling yesterday. If you can figure out a way to shovel 2 tons of snow and not affect your back- congratulations. You are either a magician, own a plow, or paid the neighborhood kids to do it for you. Nuff said.

The sprawling grounds of stately Chez What were blanketed with snow...

The sprawling grounds of stately Chez What were blanketed with snow…

Football Players & Head Traumas…

A couple of weeks ago, I posted a response to a mother who had concerns about head and neck traumas their child might incur playing soccer. I told her of a growing number of parents who allow their children to play soccer, but are specifically instructing coaches to not allow their children to ‘head’ the ball. I caught some flack for advocating this, as there are plenty of folks who feel that changes the nature of the game. My response is that it does change the nature of the game- but the flip side is that by ignoring this problem, you run the risk that the game will change the nature of your children- increasing their likelihood of neck pain and brain injury. There are people who will disagree with me on this, but this is where I stand.

I mention this specifically because of a new long term study being proposed by a partnership between the NFL and Boston University to try and better understand the risks to the central nervous system caused by repeated head traumas. The study is actually asking players in the NFL to donate their brains to science upon their demise, in an effort to study the long term anatomical changes which occur from play in the NFL. This is particularly poignant here in Philadelphia where Brian Westbrook- arguably one of the best running backs in football, has been saddled by back to back concussions which have taken him out for several games. There have been numerous calls from players, physicians and fans for him not to return and risk more serious trauma. I don’t know enough about his particular injury to say he should retire, but I am glad that the NFL is taking this problem seriously.

A new study suggests that psychology  plays a role in recovery from back pain…

A friend sent me a link to a new study which basically states that ‘mental therapy’ can help a person improve their back pain- that is, psychology is part of the overall picture of back pain. Well, DUH- Really?- this is a surprise? Bottom line: if you don’t address all of the facets associated with back & neck pain, it will never really go away. There is a triad of pain which I have elaborated on numerous times. If you take care of the physiological aspect of the pain without touching upon the ergonomics or lifestyle issues which compromised you in the first place, your pain won’t stay away. If you are recovering from an injury or trauma, and you don’t pay attention to your psychology, you are not likely to fully recover either.

If you are on the East Coast of the US- I hope you had a chance to dig yourself out-

Be Well,

Andy

Jorden Gold with a helpful comment…

Monday, December 7th, 2009

Thank you for the responses to the piriformis/sciatica post from Saturday.

I want to restate that not all sciatica is due to piriformis syndrome, and that if you have not had the cause of yours diagnosed, be sure to do so. Clearly understanding the cause will help you to resolve it faster.

A good friend of mine, Jorden Gold operates The Stretch Zone in Miami. Jorden is a stretching expert, and had this to add to my comments:

I fully agree with Doctor Kirschner, in the importance of ‘nipping it in the butt.’
Stretching the piriformis muscle is almost always necessary to relieve the pain along the sciatic nerve and there are many good documented piriformis stretches.

I strongly recommend that once the inflammation resides that you not only continue these stretches, but also add general stretches for the whole buttocks area as well.  Particularly when the sacroiliac area begins to feel tired, stiff and/or sore, these stretch/massage techniques should be done to prevent the piriformis syndrome from returning.

Example buttocks stretch-   Begin on all fours. Place the affected foot across and underneath the trunk of the body so that the affected knee is outside the trunk. Extend the non-affected leg straight back behind the trunk and keep the pelvis straight. Keeping the affected leg in place, scoot the hips backwards towards the floor and lean forward on the forearms until deep stretch is felt. Do not force body to floor.

Example piriformis/Glute massage-

Sit on the middle of a foam roller ($15-$20 on the internet) with your hands on the floor behind you.
-Sit on side of glute area w/ ankle of opposite foot
across quad.
-Balance on hand and one foot holding “hot spots” until
pain diminishes
-Roll from top of glute to middle.

Thank you for your contribution Jorden. To my viewers- if you are in the Miami area give Jorden a call- you will have an amazing experience.

Be well!

-Andy

Rainbow over New Jersy.

Rainbow over New Jersey.

Sciatica & Piriformis Syndrome

Saturday, December 5th, 2009

Viewer Question:

“My physician told me my sciatica was caused by something called piriformis syndrome. I googled it and found a lot of different explanations about what this is, and why it’s causing me pain. Could you help me to understand this a little better? Is there anything I can do about it?”   -Samantha

Well, we should probably start out with some basic anatomy and define a couple of terms…

The piriformis muscle is a short, thick muscle which runs between the sacrum (the broad flat bone at the base of your spine) and the top of the femur. This muscle stabilizes the hip and participates in rotating your hip outward when contracted.

Sciatica is a broad term for pain caused by irritation of the sciatic nerve-associated with the L5-S1 nerve root. While the cause of pain is sometimes easy to identify, pain from this nerve can have several origins, and sometimes diagnostic testing may be required to identify the specific cause of an individuals discomfort.

In most individuals, the piriformis passes over the sciatic nerve (the large nerve which runs down the back of your thigh, and causes sciatica when irritated.) In a small percentage of people, the sciatic nerve actually passes through the piriformis muscle. The space through which the sciatic nerve passes underneath the piriformis is quite small, and when the muscle becomes irritated or goes into spasm, it contracts- thickening it in its center, and constricting the space for the sciatic nerve. This reduction in space often results in irritation to the nerve, causing radiating pain down the leg. This situation is worse for individuals who’s nerve pass through the muscle itself.

Now, in my clinical experience, the longer this irritation is going on- the harder it is to treat. So if this is a new thing for you, get aggressive about taking care of it.

Now- what to do…

First things first- your doctor may have already put you on an anti-inflammatory medication such as ibuprofen. Sometimes this is a good start, as it will reduce the discomfort sufficiently to allow you to adequately stretch the muscle, and for you to have a partner apply a hands-on release of this muscle. Keep in mind, that while the medicine may help reduce your pain, it is only a transient reduction and unless you relieve the underlying cause, your pain will return. I am all about the short term use of medications whenever they are needed.

There is a simple self-stretch which you can do to help elongate and relax the muscle. If, for example, you are trying to release your left piriformis muscle- stand on the floor facing a standard height chair. Place your left foot flat on the seating surface of the chair. While leaning forward towards the chair, use your right hand to pull your left knee to the right. Gradually increase the pull while leaning forward a little farther. Apply steady pressure forward and upon your knee. Do not ‘bounce’ while stretching, as this is one area in particular which can be worsened by ‘ballistic’ type stretching.

One really effective approach for mild to moderate cases it to (carefully) cut a tennis ball in half , and to place one half flat-side-down on a chair, and to sit with the ball right in the ‘meatiest’ portion of the buttocks. This actually applies pressure directly to the center of the piriformis, and can help it to release and come out of spasm.

There are many hands-on techniques which partners can do on each other to help release the piriformis muscle- a couple of which I outline in my book and DVD, but are a little too involved to address here, as there are many techniques leading up to them.

In extreme cases of  piriformis syndrome, the area is so painful and tender, that that it is almost impossible to stretch or apply hands-on techniques. In these cases, more aggressive medical intervention can be required- either in the form of oral medications such as prednisone to help reduce inflammation or injections- either into trigger points in the muscle itself or via an epidural to reduce pain & inflammation along the nerve pathways.

Some people worry that the more aggressive medications are still just a temporary fix. The truth is, these medications can sometimes reduce the pain sufficiently to allow pain-free movement for a while, and help to restore normal body mechanics. This alone can go a long way towards getting rid of the underlying issue. While the pain is reduced, patients can the introduce the more conservative treatment approaches.

Samantha- I hope this helps to clarify things a bit. Thanks so much for your question- please keep me posted on your recovery.

The response to the Pregnancy & Back Pain posts have been great- look for Part 3 next week.

Thank you again for your comments and questions. As always, be well.

-Andy

How nice- to be able to take a nap pretty much anywhere...

How nice- to be able to take a nap pretty much anywhere…

Viewer Question: Disc Replacement Surgery

Friday, November 13th, 2009

Sarah W. sent me this question by email:

“I have had back pain for more than 20 years. When I was in high school, I twisted my back playing field hockey, and it never really felt right again. In my 20s, the pain worsened, and an MRI showed that I had a herniated disc. A cousin of mine had disc replacement surgery, and has been doing really well with it. It seems like a pretty extensive procedure. Do you think it could help me?”

Sarah,

First of all, thank you for your question.

I know that having back pain be a part of your daily life can be really tough, and there are so many options out there to provide relief, it’s hard to make sense of it all.

First, let’s talk about the disc before we go over replacing it. The intravertebral disc is a small hamburger shaped capsule which lies in between two vertebra. It consists of two primary structures; the soft center called the nucleus, and the thick fibrous ring which surrounds it, called the annulus. When we are younger, the fluid in the nucleus it thinner and more flexible. As we get older, it thickens and becomes more like silly putty. The disc serves two primary functions: 1) It helps to absorb shock between the vertebra, and 2) It articulates two adjacent vertebra, so they can move freely. There are lots of ways a disc can become damaged, most commonly a disc bulge or herniation- were the annular part of the disc becomes compromised, and the outer portion of the disc becomes mis-shapen, and then encroaches into areas and onto structures which can cause pain.

Disc replacement surgery is a relatively new option for people with severe disc damage. Basically, the soft disc in between two vertebrae is removed, and replaced with a mechanical device which simulates the movement and function the disc had before it was damaged. The procedure is often used in place of a fusion, where two vertebra are fused together. There is a relatively long recovery period from this surgery, including the first few weeks of healing and physical therapy, followed by strengthening. The initial recovery period varies in length based upon the age and overall physical condition of the patient. And based upon the patients in my practice who have undergone the surgery, it can take a full year for a patient to feel ‘normal.’

There are varying statistics on the efficacy of disc replacement surgery. In my own practice, and in discussion with several other physicians, there seems to be about a 50% chance that disc replacement will make a patients pain go away.

As to whether it is appropriate for you- that would largely depend upon your specific disc injury, and a host of other factors which I cannot address without examining you and your imaging studies. I suggest you get on line, and look for surgeons in your area who are performing the procedure, and arrange a consultation. How did your cousin’s procedure go? Do you live near your cousin? Perhaps you could meet with their doctor.

I hope this information is a little helpful, and thank you so much for your question.

-Andy

Viewer Question About Sciatica & Exercise- please read the follow up at the bottom of the post.

Sunday, May 17th, 2009

Welcome Back Lincoln Rd

Sciatica can come from lots of causes, and what may work to relieve one individual’s pain, may be completely ineffective for another. Here is a viewer question about sciatic pain and the use of McKenzie exercises.

Robin McKenzie, a physiotherapist from New Zealand, created a series of exercises designed to relieve back and neck pain. His approach suggests that all back pain is discogenic or, caused by discs. This physician strongly disagrees- there are several causes of back pain, and while McKenzie exercises are appropriate for many types of pain, most back pain seems to be caused by an amalgam of several causes- physiologic, psychological, and ergonomical. Only with a comprehensive approach including this trinity of factors, can you really find long term relief. Look for an overview of the causes of sciatica some time in May.

Thanks for the question, and as always- please keep those cards and letters coming!

The Recap!

Tuesday, March 31st, 2009

top10recap

You can reference this one video for reminders of all of the top 10.

Steroids- not all bad.

Thursday, March 19th, 2009

Hey- a couple of weeks ago, I posted a short video about epidurals. In the video, I related that the injections often contain steroids, and I received comments from 3 concerned viewers who had received epidural injections, and were not aware that steroids could be part of the medication, and had worries about steroids in general.

Unfortunately, steroids get a pretty bad rap due to all of the news- this athlete or that athlete have been accused of using steroids. While steroids are a serious class of medication, there are a two main categories commonly in use, and a little clarification is in order.

The two broad categories of steroids are anabolic steroids and corticosteroids.

The steroids you hear about on the news are of the anabolic variety, and carry with them all sorts of side effects, including muscle growth, rage, psychosis, sexual dysfunction, as well a others.

The steroids included in therapeutic injections are corticosteroids, and are used as an anti-inflammatory agent. They carry with them some potentially serious side effects when inappropriately taken or prescribed, but have many great uses when dealing with various types of pain & inflammation. These drugs should be considered largely safe for short term use when appropriately prescribed.

Oral steroids in the form of Prednisone, or the commonly prescribed Medrol Dose Pack- can be used for nerve root irritation and other nerve mediated pain syndromes. Injectable steroids can be used when more aggressive therapy is needed. These injections can be superficial, in the case of trigger pint injections. Deeper injections are often placed with flouroscopic (live x-ray) guidance, to ensure they are directed to the most accurate location.

I hope this clears things up. The steroids present in epidural injections are safe and effective, and should not give you concern.

Look for the final 2 postings on the top 10 list, as well as a recap next week.

Also check back for our first guest interview with extraordinary physical therapist, Debra Rasansky, coming Thursday.

Be Well!!