Posts Tagged ‘disc replacement’

Spinal Surgery for Back Pain: Part 1: Introduction

Wednesday, February 17th, 2010

I received so many questions about the post I did a couple of weeks ago on the surgical procedure known as a foraminotomy, and many of those questions had to do with other surgeries as well. I thought I would take the opportunity to review the basics of some of these procedures in order to get a better understanding of how these procedures work.

Surgery is the most aggressive treatment option available for relief from back pain, and should be considered only after all more conservative options have been weighed. Many patients in my own practice have come to me as a last resort before deciding whether or not to have surgery.

If you google information about the outcomes of spinal surgery, you may find that the statistics are a little discouraging. The overall statistics for patients in my own practice who have had surgery for their back pain is not too different from most of the numbers you see out there- I have observed that about 30% of patients get some relief from the surgery, 30% have virtually no improvement, and about 30% report that they actually felt worse following surgery. Now, while these numbers sound kind of dismal, they improve significantly when patients are well screened, and when you are dealing with a particularly talented surgeon (and no, I ain’t namin names!)

In the next posts, I will review a few of the more common surgical procedures for treating back and neck pain as well as radicular pain such as sciatica. We will review the foraminotomy, spinal fusion, disc repair, and disc replacement.

Now, in this introduction, let me give you some basics that apply to all types of spinal surgery;

-If you have exhausted all conservative approaches to your pain, and you are considering surgery- as with any surgery, when possible get a second opinion.

-In your area, try to find people who have had surgery, and gather information about their experiences- not only about their own outcome, but about their experiences with the surgeon, their hospital, recovery, therapy, etc…

-As with any surgery, there are inherent risks such as hemorrhage, infection, etc… I am wary of any physician which describes anything as ‘risk free’ or ‘minor surgery.’ In the world of spinal surgery, there is no such thing as minor surgery- only degrees of ‘major.’

-Be prepared to do any post operative therapy your surgeon recommends- for many procedures, the follow up is just as important as the procedure itself when it comes to a favourable outcome.

-Try and recruit friends and family members to provide a network of support both pre and postoperatively. There can be significant anxiety as well as pain & discomfort associated with any of these procedures. Having emotional support before and after surgery can help hasten recovery.

These are just a few considerations when gearing up for surgery. Over the next few installments, I hope to provide you a basic understanding of what these procedures entail. If you have had surgery for back or neck pain, please share your experiences.

Best,

Andy

sugery

Update: Upcoming topics- fibromyalgia & spinal surgery, and Happy Birthday Donna!

Wednesday, February 3rd, 2010

feb32010update

There are a few topics I have been meaning to get to- I touched upon one surgery- the foraminotomy a week ago, but there are so many other procedures out there for the spine, and some viewers had some questions about what these procedures did. In light of a few recent studies regarding the outcome of these procedures, I thought now would be a good time to start a short series on the topic. Look for a post on disc replacement surgery some time in the next few days.

Also, I have been getting many questions about fibromyalgia- what it is and more importantly, what can be done about it. Look for some informational posts as well as some tips over the next several days.

Thanks for visiting- and BE WELL!

-Andy

Today is my wife, Donna's, birthday. I love you sweetheart- Happy Birthday!

Today is my wife, Donna's, birthday. I love you sweetheart- Happy Birthday!

A further note on Disc Replacement Surgery…

Saturday, November 21st, 2009

This morning I received an email from Maria- “I have had disc replacement surgery, and it was the biggest mistake I ever made. How can you recommend this? I have had no relief, and had to go through major surgery and a long and painful recovery.”

She elaborated on all of the ways which the surgery had adversely affected her life.

Maria, please understand this- and it is important for all of my viewers to be aware of this; I try to make my posts educational, informative, and sometimes entertaining. My wish is to provide useful information about all of the back pain options out there. Everyone’s back pain situation is unique, and some approaches to relief will not be appropriate for other individuals.

In my post, I did not recommend disc replacement surgery- if anything, I feel I came across as too skeptical of the procedure. I am sorry that you did not get a positive outcome. There are people who are perfect candidates for the procedure, and even when everything is done perfectly, those people do not get relief. I have spoken with patients who had a 100 percent improvement in their pain- complete relief- following their procedure. I don’t know- and clearly at this point in this relatively new technology- I don’t think anyone knows a completely guaranteed way of identifying which patients will derive benefit.

In my area of back pain management/treatment, I will always lean towards the more conservative, less invasive approach to relief- but for some it simply is not enough. For those patients, surgery is the best option.

Again Maria- I am sorry you did not get the relief you were hoping for. I hope you can find an approach that works for you. Thank you for your question.

In the mean time, I am preparing some other video posts while I am still here in London.

Be Well,

-Andy

L1010219